While Smith Haughey Rice & Roegge attorneys are confident on both sides of the aisle, interviewees acknowledge their reputation for solid defense work, particularly in legal and medical malpractice. They primarily represent plaintiffs in commercial settings, one explains. Since opening its doors in 1941, the litigation team has grown to more than 40 partners and associates, all of whom, sources agree, are strong in their areas of expertise. Interviewees unanimously attest to Thomas McCarthy, Jr.'s impressive capabilities. "He is recognized by everyone as a star litigator," one remarks. A peer points to his unique approach to the law: "He is a songwriter and gives seminars on how to apply songwriting to persuasive trial advocacy. He's a storyteller extraordinaire - so good at telling stories and making his case a story that people want to hear." Co-chair of the firm's plaintiff personal injury practice group, McCarthy is, accordingly, a well-known specialist in the field. Recently, he served as lead counsel representing multiple estates in wrongful death cases in which plaintiffs sought multimillion-dollar verdicts. A peer also insists that professional liability star Jack Oostema "has got the world by the tail" and goes on to confirm, "I'm constantly learning from him." A client offers, "Jack is an outstanding trial lawyer and is also friendly and personable. Jack provides guidance as appropriate but is also willing to listen to clients. He is very knowledgeable, but he is not a 'know-it-all.'"
